The differences between a hoop house and a traditional greenhouse
Previous Post Next Post

The differences between a hoop house and a traditional greenhouse

Are you considering setting up a controlled environment for your plants to thrive but unsure whether to opt for a traditional greenhouse or a hoop house? You've come to the right place! This blog post will delve deep into hoop houses and traditional greenhouses, shedding light on their fundamental differences, benefits, and drawbacks. You might be familiar with greenhouses as the classic glass or polycarbonate structures designed to protect and nurture plants all year round. Still, hoop houses are an increasingly popular alternative with unique advantages. As we compare these two horticultural havens side by side, we hope to arm you with all the information you need to make the best decision for your garden's specific needs. So, please sit back, and let's embark on this educational journey together, unraveling the mysteries behind the wonderful world of plant shelters.


1. Hoop House vs. Greenhouse: Key Differences

Understanding the differences between hoop houses and greenhouses is crucial for gardeners and farmers looking to extend their growing season while utilizing their available resources efficiently. Some of the key differences between the two are:

- Structure and permanence: Greenhouses are often permanent structures made of rigid materials like glass or polycarbonate panels, while hoop houses are semi-permanent structures made from metal frames and plastic film coverings.
- Climate control: Greenhouses typically offer better climate control with permanent utility hookups, allowing gardeners to regulate temperature, ventilation, and lighting. Hoop houses rely on the natural environment and may use minimal climate control components, like portable space heaters or fans.
- Usage: Hoop houses primarily focus on protecting crops, extending the growing season, and are often used for in-ground crop cultivation, whereas greenhouses often serve other purposes, including retail and propagation, in addition to season extension.
- Cost: Greenhouses are generally more expensive than hoop houses, with more substantial foundation requirements and durable materials.

In conclusion, choosing between a hoop house and a greenhouse largely depends on your requirements, budget, and growth goals.


2. Hoop Houses for Season Extension

Hoop houses have become popular for extending the growing season, especially among small-scale farmers and gardeners. These structures offer several benefits that make them an excellent choice for season extension:

- Cost-effective: With a price range of $5 to $10 per square foot (or even less when ordered in bulk), hoop houses are typically more affordable than greenhouses, making them an attractive option for budget-conscious growers.
- Versatile design: The simple, half hoop-shaped framework of a hoop house makes it easy to assemble, disassemble, and relocate, providing flexibility in size and location to suit your needs.
- Enhanced climate protection: Hoop houses provide essential climate control and protection from frost, wind, and precipitation, contributing to a warmer environment that traps solar heat and promotes plant growth throughout the cooler months.
- High tunnel systems: Developed by the USDA, this design modification is a taller version of a hoop house that further extends the growing season while improving air and soil quality and reducing energy use.

In summary, hoop houses offer a cost-effective, adaptable, and efficient way to extend the growing season and protect your plants from harsh weather conditions, making them a viable alternative to traditional greenhouses for many growers. 


3. Greenhouses for Retail & Propagation

Greenhouses are highly versatile structures that serve multiple purposes for gardeners and farmers. One key advantage of using greenhouses is their ability to function as retail spaces and propagation centers. Below are some aspects that make greenhouses ideal for these tasks:

- Climate Control: Greenhouses are designed to maintain optimal temperatures, humidity, and airflow, creating a conducive environment for propagating plants. This controlled climate results in healthier, more robust seedlings and plants.
- Year-Round Production: Greenhouses' temperature and humidity control features enable growers to cultivate and propagate plants all year round, unaffected by external weather conditions. This continuous production helps generate consistent revenue and supply to the market.
- Variety of Plants: Greenhouses allow for cultivating a wide range of popular plants, including tropical plants and succulents in high demand. This extensive plant inventory attracts a broader customer base for retail purposes, boosting your sales and profit potential.
- Customizable Spaces: Greenhouses can easily be adapted to create retail spaces or propagation areas, facilitating the efficient use of space depending on the grower's needs. 


4. Foundation Differences: Permanent vs Semi-Permanent

Understanding the foundation differences between a hoop house and a traditional greenhouse is crucial for gardeners and farmers when selecting the proper structure for their needs. Here are some key points about the foundation types for these structures:

- Traditional greenhouses typically have permanent foundations made of concrete, serving as a solid and stable base for the structure. This type of foundation is often associated with long-term usage and climate-controlled environments, ideal for growing delicate plants that require precise conditions.

- On the other hand, hoop houses have a semi-permanent foundation, usually consisting of metal hoops anchored to the ground using stakes. This design allows for more straightforward deconstruction, relocation, or expansion as needed, making hoop houses a more versatile option for those looking to extend their growing season or protect plants temporarily.

In conclusion, understanding the foundation differences between a hoop house and a greenhouse is vital for individuals considering either structure. Assessing one's needs and long-term goals can help determine which foundation type best suits their situation. 


5. Climate Control in Greenhouses

Climate control plays a crucial role in maintaining the ideal environment within a greenhouse, ensuring the healthy growth of plants regardless of the weather conditions outside. Here are some critical aspects of climate control in greenhouses:

- Temperature: Greenhouses are designed to regulate temperature through ventilation systems, heaters, and shading mechanisms, depending on the region and seasonal requirements. This creates a consistent growing environment for various crops and ornamental plants.
- Humidity: Maintaining proper humidity levels within a greenhouse is essential for plant growth. Many modern greenhouses have automated humidity controls to manage this aspect effectively.
- Air Circulation: Good air circulation is vital for preventing the buildup of pests and diseases within a greenhouse. Advanced greenhouses boast fans, air vents, and wet wall systems to optimize air movement.
- Ventilation: Greenhouses often incorporate automatic or manually adjustable roof and side vents to enable air exchange between the inside and outside environments. This helps maintain the proper temperature, humidity, and air circulation for plant growth.
- Customization: Advanced greenhouses can control and adjust various aspects of the internal climate, making it possible to cater to a wide range of crops and plants, including tropical species and succulents with specific growing conditions. 


6. Utility Hookups: Greenhouse Advantage

One significant advantage of a greenhouse over a hoop house is the presence of utility hookups, which contribute to a more efficient and controlled growing environment. Greenhouses typically have permanent utility connections that include:

- Ventilation systems: This help regulate air circulation and maintain optimal humidity levels within the greenhouse.
- Heating units: A heating system maintains a consistent temperature, which is vital for growing certain delicate or tropical plants.
- Lighting arrangements: A dedicated lighting setup aids in better plant growth and photosynthesis throughout the year.

Overall, integrating utility hookups in a greenhouse allows for precise control over the growing conditions and offers a more stable environment for nurturing a wider variety of plants. This versatility gives commercial and hobbyist growers an edge in producing high-quality crops consistently and efficiently. 


7. Hoop House Framework & Covering

The hoop house framework and covering are essential components that play a significant role in the functionality and durability of the structure. Here are some key points to consider:

- Material options for the frame include PVC, aluminum, and steel. Each material has pros and cons, so choosing the one that suits your needs and budget is crucial.
- The covering is typically made of plastic film, which is less expensive and more flexible, enabling growers to easily install, change, and maintain the coverage as needed.
UV-resistant plastic is recommended to ensure longevity and prevent damage from long-term exposure to sunlight.
- It is important to consider air circulation when planning the covering to ensure proper ventilation within the hoop house. This can be achieved by using appropriate vents, doors, and windows.

In conclusion, selecting the right framework and covering for your hoop house is critical in providing a nurturing environment for your plants and ensuring the structure's longevity. 


8. Is a Hoop House as Good as a Greenhouse?

Several factors come into play when deciding whether a hoop house is as good as a greenhouse. Both structures offer a controlled growth environment for plants, but there are significant differences in cost, aesthetics, and durability:

- Cost: Hoop houses are generally much more cost-effective, with their cost per square foot being approximately eight to ten times less than a greenhouse. Polyethylene materials and UV protection advancements have made hoop houses increasingly durable, offering great value for money.
- Aesthetics: Traditional greenhouses, especially Victorian-style glass structures, are often considered more attractive than hoop houses. However, some modern, sophisticated hoop house designs can be equally pleasing to the eye.
- Durability: Glass is more durable than plastic and can last for decades without showing wear and tear. However, safety glass used in greenhouses is nearly as strong as polyester for hoop houses, making them comparably resilient.

The choice between a greenhouse and a hoop house will largely depend on personal preferences, budget, and specific requirements. 


9. Modern Greenhouse vs. Traditional & DIY

Modern greenhouses have evolved significantly from the traditional structures that adorned gardens in the past. While traditional greenhouses were built using wood or brick with glass windows, modern greenhouses often utilize more economical and lightweight materials like PVC, aluminum, or fiberglass. "There used to be a clear-cut line between hoop houses and greenhouses but these days that line is getting rather fuzzy," notes Survival Jack.

- Modern greenhouses are typically more miniature and user-friendly, catering to DIY garden enthusiasts.
- They often incorporate shelves for potted plants, as opposed to the larger spaces in hoop houses, which can accommodate in-ground planting.
- Air circulation and heating systems in modern greenhouses can be controlled more precisely than in traditional structures.

In conclusion, while traditional greenhouses may carry nostalgic charm, modern greenhouses offer improved efficiency, versatility, and adaptability for various garden settings and budgets. 


10. Air Circulation & Heating: Hoop House vs Greenhouse

Various factors differentiate a hoop house from a traditional greenhouse, particularly regarding air circulation and heating. These primary differences include the following:

- Climate Control: Greenhouses offer better climate control than hoop houses due to their permanent structure and built-in systems. They have ventilation, humidity control, and heating, allowing for year-round plant growth.

- Size and Structure: Hoop houses are typically larger and taller than greenhouses, allowing for more natural air circulation, but lack the advanced climate control systems found in greenhouses.

- Heating Options: Greenhouses often have built-in heaters and proper insulation. In contrast, hoop houses may require additional external heating sources, such as propane heaters, during colder months.

In conclusion, hoop houses and traditional greenhouses provide unique advantages regarding air circulation and heating. Greenhouses excel in climate control and year-round plant cultivation. At the same time, hoop houses offer larger space and the ability to extend the growing season with the help of external heating sources.

Related Posts

Previous Post Next Post
Back to blog